a Business Spectator publication

Where do EU carbon prices go from here?

LONDON (Reuters) – The price of European carbon permits have risen around 10 per cent this month after political unrest in the Middle East, Japan's earthquake and Germany's decision to shut down old nuclear capacity.

EUAs for delivery in December 2010 peaked at €17.75 a tonne on March 16 – their highest level since November 2008 – triggered by a nuclear crisis in Japan and a German government move to shut a third of its nuclear capacity.

After retreating to below €17, prices hit an eight-day high of €17.35 in early trade on Monday, after a Green Party victory in Germany's state elections suggested that Germany would rely more heavily on coal plants, thereby pushing up emissions.

Several traders and analysts see prices gaining more momentum this week, before shedding a euro or two in the spring due to reduced power demand and generation.

"A new upward trend seems to be on the horizon," said Matteo Mazzoni, carbon analyst at Italy's Nomisma Energia.

The German election outcome, an increase in spot trading and the release of European Union 2010 verified emissions data could drive carbon prices higher this week, Mazzoni said.

BUY

After Sunday's election, the Greens, which secured the second-largest number of votes, are widely expected to form a coalition with the socialist party, which could lead to the permanent shut down of 7-8 gigawatts of nuclear capacity.

"That means around 70 million tonnes of extra carbon dioxide will be emitted and carbon is up on this prospect for now," said Emmanuel Fages at Societe Generale/orbeo.

Spot trade is also likely to increase as more national EU emissions registries reopen.

Any heightened trading activity could help carbon's upward momentum.
However, prices would have to break through the €17.50 level to lead to higher gains, traders said.

The EU Commission's release of verified emissions data for 2010 on Friday could help fuel that rise. Analysts expect the bloc's emissions to have risen by 2-4 per cent last year.

If the rise is stronger and the market remains in surplus of EUAs, it could help carbon break through €17.50 toward the next key level of €18.60, said OTC Europe's Brett Genus.

But traders will be monitoring technical factors like changes in open interest to gauge if prices are likely to slip again.

Any resulting dips in price would be an opportunity to buy, Genus said.

SELL

EU emissions data is unlikely to affect prices, according to Barclays Capital analyst Trevor Sikorski.

"The market is likely to be neither shaken nor stirred by Friday's numbers as the forecast balance for the phase is long some 450 million tonnes of EUAs – and market pricing already reflects this balance. It would take something outside the expected increase of 2-4 per cent to be a surprise," he said.

More long-term gains will much depend upon utilities' hedging patterns. Warmer weather in Spring will also reduce power and thereby EUA demand, which could temper gains.

"I think the price will remain around €17 or increase a bit more this week but I don't think it will go to €20 as there will be less power and electricity demand in spring which should make it go down a euro," said Fages at Societe Generale/orbeo.

Comments on this article

German elections

Err, there were two state elections held in Germany on Sunday (and one last week). This article appears to be referring to the result in Baden-Württemberg, where the Greens will be the major coalition partner with the SPD, but in Rhineland-Palatinate the Greens also recorded a swing of >10% and will form a coalition with the SPD, this time as minor partner.

 

Even without speaking German, these graphs should make it fairly clear: http://stat.tagesschau.de/wahlen/2011-03-27-EVENT-BWRP/index.shtml

 

The German results are important beyond the local context because states have respresentatives in the Federal upper house.

Is Nuclear a friend or foe

Is this wave of fear around Nuclear new, or has it just spread to politicians? In Nuclear our friend or foe? Most projections for energy use include nuclear in the mix. To reduce carbon emissions it is certainly a good choice. It is ironic that whilst Germany wants to shot down Nuclear facilities, France is a net exporter of nuclear power. Further, were France to experience some sort of Nuclear fallout from one of its reactors, it would impact all of Europe.